Removing an emulsifier without losing shelf stability
Petal & Grain wanted to remove a synthetic emulsifier from a sauce while keeping its two-week shelf stability, but every substitution separated the product and no known clean-label swap held the emulsion.
Technological uncertainty (T661 line 242)
“We reformulated our sauce to remove an additive, which took a lot of trial and error.”
“It was uncertain whether the emulsion could be held for the two-week shelf life without the synthetic emulsifier. Known clean-label alternatives destabilized under the product's pH and thermal-processing conditions, and it was unknown whether any accessible combination could maintain the emulsion through distribution.”
'Trial and error' alone does not establish uncertainty. The strong version explains why the known alternatives could not be assumed to work under the specific conditions.
Technological advancement (T661 line 246)
“We found a formulation that works without the additive.”
“We advanced our understanding of stabilizing this emulsion at the product's pH: a specific hydrocolloid blend processed in a revised shear sequence held stability across accelerated shelf-life testing. We also established that increasing a single stabilizer caused a texture defect, which ruled out that approach.”
The strong version states what was learned about the formulation-process interaction, with a documented failed direction.
What could support a claim like this
The matrix pairs each described element with the kind of source that could support it. The actual records still need review.
| Source | What it shows |
|---|---|
| Formulation trials | The substitutions tested and which ones separated |
| Stability testing data | Accelerated shelf-life results per formulation |
| Sensory records | The texture/appearance outcomes that ruled approaches in or out |
| Process-run logs | The shear and thermal conditions each trial used |
The takeaway
A new flavour does not establish eligibility. Follow the separate stability investigation through its conditions, results and conclusions, then review that work against both CRA requirements.
Draft yours from real evidence
Use approved GitHub activity, uploaded documents and project records to prepare an editable narrative draft for review.
7-day free trial · No credit card required